Bert, his left shoulder bleeding, came up the street with a sour look on his face and rolled Willie’s body over with the toe of his boot. As the body turned over, a growing pile of gold coins spilled out of Willie’s shredded, bullet-riddled shirt. Bert quickly understood the reason why the man had been able to take several gunshots to his midsection without so much as receiving a nick. Though the face he looked down at was now missing its left eye and had been bloodied, Bert could still easily identify it as Wil­lie Dunhill’s. He was sickened by the high price Phil Roberts had paid for tracking down the wily, one-armed snake. Bert had his own theory on Wil­lie’s probable paymaster for all the gold that now laid in a pile next to his lifeless body.

  “Well son, you best give me that pistol now,” Bert said to John, who was still lying in the middle of the street, pistol in hand.

  Taking the pistol from John, Bert turned and was surprised to find Tom Burton on the boardwalk nearby. Looking at Burton, Bert motioned toward Willie’s dead body and then toward John, and asked, “These two yours?”

  “John Barton there is one of my best riders. I’ve no idea who the one-armed hombre was,” Burton said, meeting Bert’s stone-eyed glare with one of his own.

  “I met the man in a saloon in Saint Joe two months ago. I don’t know him other than he had a friend who liked to fight,” John volunteered, hop­ing he wouldn’t need to say more.

  “Did he always wear such fancy duds?” Bert pressed, looking at John.

  “Not sure. I guess he did. I thought he was a cowpuncher,” John said shrugging his shoulders.

  Recognizing the fancy hat and vest Willie was wearing as once be­longing to José Rodriquez, John’s mind raced to understand what might have happened between the two men. That Willie also had José’s distinctive eyepatch around his neck seemed to confirm he had probably killed the man. When and why, John had no idea.

  “A one-armed, left-handed, gunslingin’ cowpuncher who liked to wear fancy duds and wrap himself in gold coins. Well, it takes all kinds, I guess,” Bert said, letting everyone in earshot know he wasn’t happy with the answers he was getting or with how things had worked out.

  With Willie’s death, Bert’s only lead on the Mexican cattle-rustling raid had also died. He knew of no one else who could tie the raid to Tom Burton. It was certain none of Burton’s men would talk for fear of reprisal. How Burton and Dunhill happened to be in the same town on the same boardwalk at the same time seemed too coincidental, but then there was the question of the link between Willie Dunhill and John Barton, a link Barton himself had acknowledged. 

  The ugly twist in the tale that soured Bert’s stomach was that he would now have to pay John Barton, the man who had conveniently severed his mysterious link with Willie Dunhill with a bullet to man’s brain, the two-hundred-dollar reward for bringing Willie in. Whatever their link had been, it was clear the two men hadn’t exactly been friends. 

  Bert had to shake his head and grudgingly accept there would remain many questions unanswered when it came to the mysterious Willie Dun­hill. That he had been a one-armed man had come as a shock, considering he had somehow been a cowpuncher according to Barton. Looking back at Willie’s dead body sprawled out in the street, Bert took note of the ornate eyepatch that hung around the man’s neck, which triggered yet another question for which he had no answer, and for which he expected he never would. He had to concede that only a higher power would be able to answer the question of how Willie Dunhill had known he would be needing an eyepatch in hell.

The genesis of this novel is a Barton family myth that has been passed down through the generations for more than 140 years. It has been said that the Barton brothers rode with the James brothers after the Civil War. During these outlaw days, my great-great grandfather ran off with Cole Younger’s sweetheart. It has been further claimed that she may have been part Seneca or Cherokee Indian. As the tale has been told, the couple first met along a small river in northwest Missouri where she was doing laundry. They fell in love, later ran off, got married, and had children who continued the Barton family march west into the Dakota Territory and beyond. 

The hero of the tale as I have tried to reconstruct events is Bill Barton who was born in Illinois in 1845 to Amorett Waite and Oromal Bingham Barton. Bill Barton moved from Illinois to Iowa shortly after the Civil War in 1865. John Barton, Bill Barton’s oldest son, was born in Iowa in 1868. John married in Iowa in 1897 and had seven children—three sons and four daughters—and later homesteaded at Rainy Creek near the little town of Creighton, Pennington County in western South Dakota in 1912. John’s oldest son, Bill Barton, named for his grandfather, later married Kathrine (Kate) Busskohl and had three children—two sons, Harold and John, and one daughter, Velda, my mother. From 1929 until 1935, Bill and Kate Barton homesteaded the last available free land near Dewey in Custer County in the Black Hills of South Dakota not far from where gold was first discovered on French Creek in 1874. 

I have spun both fact and fiction into this epic tale, drawing from historical facts about the Barton family as well as facts surrounding: Jesse and Frank James; Cole, Jim, Bob, and John Younger; William Quantrill; Bloody-Bill Anderson; Clell Miller; Charlie Pitts; Bill Chadwell; Belle Starr; Judge Shirley; Allen Pinkerton; General George Armstrong Custer; Capitan Leander McNelly; Dan Rice; and many others as well as drawing from the many accounts of the Northfield, Minnesota bank robbery and the ensuing manhunt. The story roughly takes place over a ten-year period from the end of the Civil War in 1865 to the presidential election in 1876. 

As it happens, the year 1876 marks a watershed in American history. Many tectonic events converged during the preceding decade that have in many ways set the foundations of the America in which we live today. From the purchase of the Alaska territory, the completion of the first transcontinental railroad, the rise of the Pinkerton National Detective Agency (later to evolve into today’s FBI), the opening of the last Indian lands in the Dakotas, and the celebration of America’s first centennial, to the globalization of the ice trade, the establishment of America’s modern day Christmas traditions, the discovery of the telephone, the death of George Armstrong Custer at the Battle of the Little Big Horn, the running of the first Kentucky Derby, the demise of the James-Younger Gang in Northfield, Minnesota, and the contested presidential election of 1876 which led to the sudden decision to withdraw federal troops and end southern reconstruction, resulting in the loss of civil rights for millions of newly freed slaves for nearly one hundred years. All these events and many more have been woven into the story, each playing a role in helping to set the stage and propel the plot forward. In writing this fictional account, I found it necessary to include a few historical facts, believing we are all products of the times in which we live. Bill Barton and Lucy Breeden were no different. 

This is a work of fiction, none of the characters or events depicted in this story are intended to represent any true persons either living or deceased or their true actions or intentions or any actual historical events. This fictional novel is at best a flight of fancy based on a long-held Barton family myth. The author’s intent is to entertain, not to inform readers of the accurate recounting of historical persons, facts, or events. The author reserves the right to leave the writing of history to historians. As to those things that may be plausible, the author believes the realm of the possible is limited only by an understanding of the facts and your own imagination. 

Bill Bishop 

Hot Springs, South Dakota

July 22, 2018